From “Pepper Pig” to Your Next Idea

At Revival Supper Club, we believe in bringing life back to the table, and sometimes, the quickest way to inject pure joy and boundless creativity into your dinner party is with a punny theme.

Forget generic “Italian Night’ or “Taco Tuesday.” While those are perfectly fine for family dinner night ideas, there’s a special kind of magic that happens when your supper club theme makes your guests chuckle. This sparks curiosity over what culinary delights await! A clever pun sets a playful tone, drives culinary creativity, and gives everyone a fun framework to build upon.

Let’s dive into the art of the punny supper club theme, using a past favorite, “Pepper Pig,” as a cheeky and fun example.

Beyond the obvious cartoon humor here, a punny theme does so much for your gathering:

• Memorability: People remember “Pepper Pig” far more easily than “Pork and Peppers Dinner.”
• Sets the Tone: It immediately signals that this isn’t just any supper club; it’s a creative, fun, and playful experience!
• Sparks Creativity: For your collaborative supper club, a pun is a fantastic springboard for dish ideas, musical choices, and even decor.
• Builds Anticipation: Guests will be guessing and excited to see how you (and everyone else) interprets the theme.

Case Study: Our “Pepper Pig” Supper Club Unpacked

“Pepper Pig” didn’t actually start with a food pairing; it began one ordinary afternoon when my child was watching Peppa Pig and joking that Peppa sounded a lot like pepper, and suddenly a spark ignited. I thought, “What if we took this playful name, Pepper Pig, and transformed it into a supper club theme?” From there, the culinary pieces began to fall into place rather quickly. Peppers and pork are a versatile pairing that works beautifully together. Two ingredients, inspired by a quirky little cartoon, became a theme born from everyday inspiration, proving that bringing life back to the table can start anywhere you find a culinary spark!

The Theme: Pepper Pig

The Core Concept: All dishes must feature pork and peppers

How It Ignited Creativity:

• The Menu: This theme was a dream for my foodie friends! We had everything from a spicy pork and pepper stir-fry, pork tenderloin with roasted pepper salsa, bacon-wrapped jalapeño poppers, and even chocolate-drizzled jalapeño bacon! The variety was incredible, proving how a simple pun could lead to a diverse, multi-course meal featuring both ingredients!
• The Playlist: This was truly where “Pepper Pig” fun extended beyond the plate. I scoured songs for any mention of bacon, pork, pig, and peppers. To my surprise, there were a great number of songs I was able to utilize in my Pepper Pig Playlist, think everything from “Pork and Beans” by Weezer to “Ham ‘N’ Eggs” by A Tribe Called Quest to “Green Peppers” by Herb Alpert & The Tijuana Brass.
• The Decor: I didn’t need to go overboard. I had a few silly, pig-themed kitchen utensils, vibrant pepper-themed hand towels, and colorful mini peppers as a decorative centerpiece.

“Pepper Pig” was a testament to how a simple pun could transform a dinner into a memorable, joy-filled event, proving that bringing life back to the table can be both delicious and delightfully whimsical.

Your Guide to Crafting Your Own Punny Supper Club Themes:

Ready to inject some playful genius into your next gathering? I have found that the best punny themes often start with an element that’s ripe for wordplay, and then you let creativity flow from there.

Step 1: Start with an Anchor

Think about a central element you want to build around. This could be:

• A Food/Ingredient: Bacon, pizza, cheese, berry, bread, chocolate, spice
• A Concept/Vibe: Chill, hot, sweet, sour, light, dark, rustic, sparkling
• A Pop Culture Reference/Name: A movie, show, song, famous person, fictional character, book

Step 2: Identify your Punnable Element

This is the SPARK! It can be an ingredient, a concept, or a piece of pop culture, just to get started

• Thinking about a pizza-themed supper club but don’t want to see a bunch of pizza? What’s an element that pizza generally has? Slices. What other foods are served in slices? Cakes, lasagna, pies, even charcuterie meats and cheeses! If we form a supper club idea around slices and pair it with a pop song, Ice Ice Baby, then we have another punny supper club idea, Slice Slice Baby!
• Thinking about a crepe-themed supper club, where every dish is a unique, delicious crepe? What does ‘crepe’ sound like when you say it quickly, especially when you’re surprised? You guessed it! Just like that, an everyday phrase led us to another funny pun: Holy Crepe!, a supper club idea centered around a delightful variety of both sweet and savory crepes!
• Thinking about a sandwich themed supper club? When I think about food we often consume that involves bread, I think about buns. What about a Top Bun theme? This opens the door to a variety of bun-inspired dishes involving: gourmet burgers and sliders, po’ boys and banh mi, and even bao buns. You can pull in decorative and sonic elements from Top Gun: planes, Tom Cruise, and aviators – the sky’s the limit!
• You love bacon, and you know your guests do, too! How can we make bacon the star without just serving side dishes? What’s a famous song that could get a delicious twist? “Don’t Go Breaking My Heart” instantly comes to mind. Swap “Breaking” for “Bacon,” and suddenly you’ve got Don’t Go Bacon My Heart, a supper club where every dish features that irresistible ingredient!

Step 3: Define Your Culinary (and Creative!) Focus

Now, this is where your punny theme truly comes alive! Clearly define what foods, ingredients, flavors, and even the overall vibe your newly punned theme will revolve around. This step guides the entire supper club experience, from the menu to the music and decor.

Here are some examples of how a punny theme can translate into a full-blown culinary adventure:

• Slice Slice Baby:
  • The Focus: This theme is all about dishes served in slices! Think beyond traditional pizza to include savory tarts, lasagnas, sliced charcuterie meats and cheeses, and of course sweet pies and cakes. It’s a visually appealing and satisfying theme that allows for endless variations in form and flavor.
• Holy Crepe!
  • The Focus: An entire meal built around crepes! Guests bring a variety of crepes, from savory crepes filled with chicken, creamy mushrooms, or rich cheese to sweet crepes bursting with fruits or chocolate.
• Top Bun
  • The Focus: We’re talking gourmet burgers, sliders, and sandwiches that reach supersonic speeds of flavor! This theme opens the door to endless creativity with a focus on the fillings and perfect bun. Think juicy beef burgers, chicken sliders, globally-inspired banh mi and fluffy bao buns. It’s a high-flying, satisfying theme that elevate casual fare.
• Don’t Go Bacon My Heart
  • The Focus: A delicious declaration of love for bacon! Every dish features the irresistible smoky, salty, crunch. Think bacon-wrapped appetizers, rich carbonara, sweet-and-savory bacon-infused desserts (like candied bacon,) and even bacon-fat roasted vegetables. This theme is all about indulging in pure, unadulterated bacon bliss.

Beyond the Pun: Bringing Your Theme to Life:

A brilliant punny theme is just the starting point! It’s delicious dishes, the thoughtfully curated music, and the clever decor that truly bring life back to the table and make your supper club an unforgettable experience.

Ready to plan your next uniquely themed gathering?

Explore more Host Your Own Supper Club section for more DIY content.

Want a head start? Grab our FREE Revival Supper Club Starter Kit and get instant access to planning checklists, theme brainstormers, and delegation tips.

What’s the most creative (or punny!) dinner party theme you’ve ever hosted or heard of? Share your ideas in the comments below – we’d love to be inspired by you!